A Commonplace Killing by Sian Busby is a historical crime thriller set in post-World War II London. The book begins when two schoolboys find a body of a woman in a bomb-damaged area in North London in July of 1946. The police suspect a sexually motivated crime, but it is much more complex than they had suspected.
The body is of a respectable woman, Lillian Frobisher, from a neighbourhood scarred by the war. She is a wife and a mother. Detective Inspector Jim Cooper is put at the helm of this case. In the beginning, the police believed this was a sexually motivated crime. But there is no evidence suggesting assault, which makes Cooper dive deeper into the life of Lillian. As he finds more information about her personal life, there are many questions that come along with it. The story’s narrative shifts from Cooper in the present to Lillian leading up to her murder. This helped me get two perspectives on the mystery.
The setting of the book is like a character itself. The recreation and descriptions of post-war London with bomb sites on the streets and food rationing create a bleak picture of the exhausted and damaged city. The main theme of the book is the psychological effect of war. The war has ended, but there is damage everywhere. Almost every character is emotionally wounded and damaged by what they survived. It explores how the war changed the identity, morality, and relationships. This gives the book a very melancholic tone.
Another theme that I thought was prominent is loneliness. Lillian’s husband goes off to war, and she is left behind. She tries hard to search for a purpose and emotional connection in a world that has gone numb. Detective Cooper, too, embodies this theme. He is emotionally reserved, isolated, and haunted by the missed opportunities in love. His introspection is the reason for the strong empathy he feels towards Lillian. Meanwhile, Lillian’s character starts going beyond being just a victim. It shows her struggle between duty and desire, along with the effects of what she survived during the war.
Jim is not the typical glamorous detective. He is weary, introspective, and deeply human. His emotional vulnerability makes him one of the novel’s strongest elements. Rather than being driven purely by justice, he is motivated by empathy and loneliness. I think the dual character POV really helps you understand the complete picture of the mystery surrounding the murder and the lead-up to it. I felt it also added a lot of emotional gravity to the story.
A Commonplace Killing by Sian Busby is an interesting historical crime thriller. The mystery and final revelation are slightly understated than what I expected. The pace of the story is slow because it focuses on complex emotional aspects. Overall, I liked the emotional grounding this story had with setting, characters, and atmosphere, all supporting it.
*Click on the book cover above to get a copy.
Books and blues 